'IMPACT' Rugby North West Leagues Providing grass roots rugby since 2002

Minutes of Committee Meeting - 10 June 2026


NORIWUL Meeting – 10 November 2026


Duration: 58 minutes 


Attendees:• Paul Riordan• John Powell• Fred Swarbrick• Aaron Howorth (RFU)• Craig Hine• Chris Farmiloe• Mark Ashley• Peter Rhodes• Tommy Hughes

1.   Electronic Match Cards (EMCs) – Adoption & Performance

  1. 1.1 Current Completion Rates                                                    Aaron provided an update on EMC adoption across divisions:              • Prem & Div 1: Above 80% completion – in line with expectations after one full season.                                                                      • Div 4 North & Central: Strong performance (83% – credit to Chris). • Div 1: Historically high completion (~90%).                                   • Div 4 West & Div 5 West: Lowest completion rates, below 50%.    1.2 Early Season Issues                                                                  • Some clubs claimed they were unaware. EMCs were mandatory despite extensive communication between July–August.                      • User errors remain the main cause of issues, not system faults:      o Players allocated to wrong teams (e.g., Wigan case).                      o Incorrect permissions.                                                                 o Lack of understanding of the “Confirm Score” step.                    1.3 Club Engagement                                                                     • RFU ran webinars, drop ins and support sessions, but uptake was low (only Southport attended one session).                                        • League secs have been directing clubs to Aaron for support, which has helped resolve issues quickly.                                                      1.4 Required Actions                                                                       • Key issue: Many clubs submit match cards without confirming the score.                                                                                            • Aaron will produce a one page guidance sheet explaining:o “Confirm Score”o “Submit Match Card”                                                          • This will be shared via WhatsApp groups, websites and social media.                                                                                        1.5 Cup Games                                                                             • Cup matches will use EMCs, but no proactive communication will be sent to clubs this week.                                                                    • Monitoring will resume the following week.

2. Player Registration & Team Sustainability
2.1 Registration Trends                                                                        • RFU data suggests player registrations are down nationally compared to last year.                                                                                                 • Aaron is cross checking RFU insights vs actual club data due to inconsistencies (e.g., Chester showing only 84 registered players).          2.2 Registration Types                                                                         • Clarification provided:o CR (Club Registered): Eligible for lower team rugby only.o RFU Registered: Required for Level 5+ first team rugby.          • Players must still be assigned to teams in GMS even if registered.          2.3 Impact on Lower Teams                                                                  • First teams taking large squads reduces availability for 2nd/3rd teams.   • Discussion around whether squad size limits should be reviewed at Level 5 and below.                                                                                             • Any change would require governance approval (National League Rugby, ROCs, ACMSC, Community Game Board).

 

                                                                                                              3. Club Development & Support
3.1 New RFU Staffing Structure                                                            • Regionalisation has introduced:                                                             o 2 new Club Developers (Lancashire & Cheshire)                                     o 1 new CB & Club Development Manager                                                • Aaron is directing these staff to focus on clubs with:                               o High concession rates                                                                           o Low player retention                                                                             o Repeated walkovers                                                                             o EMC non compliance                                                                             3.2 Priority Clubs Identified                                                                 • Three South and Five West highlighted as the most challenged leagues.     • Specific issues in Wirral area (5 West):                                                   o Clubs regularly short of players.                                                           o Frequent borrowing of players across clubs.                                           o Instances of teams offering to play under another club’s shirt to avoid concessions.                                                                                       3.3 Planned RFU Interventions                                                            • Aaron to speak with Fiona and Dave Westead regarding:                          o Potential amalgamation of clubs to secure a dedicated development officer.                                                                                                    o Additional funding for Wirral based adult male retention initiatives.          • RFU exploring “Adult Social Rugby” models similar to Cumbria’s approach to boost participation.
                                                                                                              4. League Administration Feedback
4.1 League Sec Observations                                                              • Some clubs consistently fail to complete EMCs (“serial offenders”).           • Paul suggested passing these clubs directly to Aaron for targeted intervention.                                                                                             • John emphasised:o Each club should have a named EMC contact plus a backup.                                                                                                 o He sends reminders on Thursdays/Fridays to improve compliance.       4.2 Club Communication Challenges                                                    • Internal communication within clubs remains a major barrier.                 • Fixture secretaries often fail to cascade RFU updates to team admins.
                                                                                                            5. Social Media & Cup Promotion                                                         • Craig has produced promotional content for each cup competition.            • Encouraged league secs to share posts via the North West Intermediate Rugby Leagues Facebook page.                                                               • Potential sponsorship interest received from “Hope Edwards” (stretch/recovery studio).
                                                                                                            6. Overall AssessmentAaron’s view:                                                     • EMC adoption is progressing well overall.                                                • Completion rates above 50% across the region represent strong early stage compliance.                                                                                    • Continued support, communication and targeted intervention will improve consistency.                                                                                            • The Northwest remains one of the strongest regions nationally for league completion and club engagement.